> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.bexus.info/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# ‘Political Scapegoat’: Ex-707th Chief Kim Hyun-tae’s Appeal Opens as Defense Calls First Trial ‘Void’ and Court Cool to Assembly Site Inspection
- URL: https://www.bexus.info/20261102-news-396-en/
- Published: 2026-11-09T01:17:32.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-09T01:17:32.000Z
- Description: Seoul High Court Div. 12-2 held an appeal preparatory hearing on the 2nd for seven officers incl. ex-707th chief Kim Hyun-tae. His side calls the first trial void over an unlawful panel, seeks an Assembly site inspection; court doubts re-enactment applies, defers. First instance: 9 years, Kim 12.
- Author: Alfred Kim
- Tags: english, 서울

Seoul

Kim Hyun-tae, former commander of the 707th Special Mission Group of the Army Special Warfare Command (former colonel), who was sentenced to 12 years in prison in the first instance and taken into custody in the courtroom, denied all charges at his appeal hearing on the 2nd and demanded a site inspection at the National Assembly. Seoul High Court Criminal Division 12-2 (High Court Judges Jo Jin-gu, Kim Min-ah and Lee Seung-cheol) held that afternoon a preparatory hearing in the case (No. 2026No2154) in which Kim and six other military officers are charged with participating in key insurrection duties, among other offenses. Kim’s side argued that the very composition of the first-instance panel was unlawful and that the trial was therefore void from the start, and the court deferred its decision on the site inspection, saying it doubted that “the results of a re-enactment at the site can be applied to the situation at the time.” Over the same dispatch to the National Assembly, the first-instance court sentenced Kwak Jong-keun, the former Special Warfare commander who ordered the dispatch, to nine years in prison and Kim, who received the order, to 12 years.

## Kim’s side: “First trial void from the start”… denies subversive purpose and riot alike

Of the seven defendants, five appeared in court that day: Park Heon-su, former head of the Defense Ministry Investigation Headquarters; Kim Dae-woo, former head of the Defense Counterintelligence Command investigation unit; Lee Sang-hyun, former commander of the 1st Airborne Special Forces Brigade; Kim Hyun-tae; and Kim Bong-kyu, former head of the Defense Intelligence Command central interrogation unit. A preparatory hearing is a procedure to sort out the grounds for appeal, the issues and the evidence plan before full-scale trial hearings, and defendants are not required to attend. Both the defense and the insurrection special counsel team (Special Counsel Cho Eun-suk) appealed the first-instance ruling.

Kim’s side said: “Our position is that the preceding trial itself is void from the start, so the proceedings of this panel are themselves unconstitutional.” Kim’s side also said: “There could be no purpose of subverting the constitution, there was no awareness of a riot, and there was no riot itself.” Kim’s side has filed its statement of grounds for appeal four times and, arguing that the first-instance panel, formed under the special act that set the composition and jurisdiction of the panels dedicated to insurrection cases, was unlawful, demanded a swift ruling on its petition to revoke detention and its motion to request a constitutional review of the law. The court replied that it was examining both the revocation of detention and the motion to request a constitutional review.

Kim had been tried in a military court as an active-duty serviceman, and after the special act took effect the case was transferred to the Seoul Central District Court. Defense lawyer Lee Ha-sang argued at a bail hearing in October that this transfer was “unlawful.” At the same hearing, Kim said: “I think that soldiers including myself, police officers and many public officials became political scapegoats after martial law.” The court rejected the bail request on Oct. 21.

The side of Jung Seong-wook, former head of the 2nd Business Unit of the Defense Intelligence Command’s 100th Brigade, also argued that the purpose of subverting the constitution must be judged separately for each defendant. Jung’s side said that because the purpose of subverting the constitution is a subjective element beyond intent in the crime of insurrection, strict proof beyond reasonable doubt is required. Jung’s side said the first instance held him responsible as the special counsel argued without applying the legal doctrine of joint principals, and asked for the legal findings to be reconsidered. Koo Sam-hoe, former commander of the Army 2nd Armored Brigade, and Bang Jeong-hwan, former head of the Defense Innovation Planning Office, who took part in the so-called ‘Lotteria meeting,’ were acquitted by another panel, which did not find a purpose of subverting the constitution.

## Kim demands site inspection, but court defers decision

Kim’s side said: “In light of the communication records and Kim’s movements, it is clear there was no riot,” and “the site inspection must be adopted.” Given a chance to speak, Kim said: “As the only person who was at the scene, I say the site inspection is necessary. It takes at least five minutes for 19 people to climb through a window. You have to go to the site to know.” The claim is that the first-instance finding that Kim broke a window after receiving a call from Kwak and let troops in does not match the actual timing and movements.

Kim’s side also pointed out that there were people of unknown identity inside the National Assembly at the time and that the 707th troops, an anti-terrorism unit, perceived them as possibly being terrorists. To confirm this, Kim’s side applied for a fact-finding request to the National Assembly Secretariat on the entry routes and closed-circuit television (CCTV) records of unidentified persons. The aim is to compare them with the movements of the 707th troops.

The court said: “It appears that the date and time, movements, actions and communication records at the time are already confirmed as evidence,” and “I doubt that the results of a re-enactment at the site can be applied to the situation at the time.” While signaling a negative view on adopting the site inspection, the court said “We will not decide now and will give it careful thought,” and told the defense to submit a written opinion supplementing the need for it. The court also said: “The scene that day was extremely chaotic.”

Kim’s counsel stressed that an appeal trial is also a trial on the facts and that, under the principle of trial-centered proceedings, the presiding judge must personally observe and decide. Counsel argued that the media footage used as evidence in the first instance had been edited by news organizations and might therefore be contaminated. Counsel said that in the first instance the defense applied to call witnesses four times, twice each, but all were rejected. Citing the finding on the power cut on pages 5 to 7 of the first-instance ruling, counsel argued that the passage saying that switching off the power inside the National Assembly paralyzed the plenary chamber and the Assembly’s legislative functions as a whole rests on a judge’s inference rather than on evidence. In an opinion filed on Oct. 28, the special counsel took the position that the defense’s evidence applications should be rejected, and Kim’s side filed a rebuttal on the 2nd.

## Court adopts special counsel’s witness but declines Democratic Party lawmakers as witnesses

The court adopted as a witness Kim Sang-yong, former deputy head of the Defense Ministry Investigation Headquarters, whom the special counsel had applied to call. The court said his testimony might overlap with that given in the first instance, but that some points need verification. Park Heon-su’s side opposed, saying “it is appropriate to reject.” The special counsel said it would file a separate document once it decided which 707th troops to question.

Of the evidence applied for by Kim’s side, the court accepted the photographic evidence submitted on Oct. 2, the fact-finding request on the 707th Special Mission Group’s training plan, and the request for transmission of the evidence list in the case of Lee Jin-woo, former commander of the Capital Defense Command. On the fact-finding request to the National Assembly Secretariat, it adopted only some of the 25 items. It decided to rule on the video evidence applied for on Oct. 19 after hearing the special counsel’s opinion.

Kim’s side also applied to call as witnesses Democratic Party of Korea lawmakers Kim Byung-joo, Park Sun-won and Park Beom-kye and others, who visited or met Kwak right after martial law in December 2024\. The court said, in effect, that their relevance was low, and told the defense to use other means such as fact-finding requests for the lawmakers’ testimony and to substitute existing materials. It adopted one witness related to the defense of the National Assembly and deferred its decision on calling former commander Lee Jin-woo. Kim’s side withdrew its application to call Kwak. Kim’s side said that if it sees the need for evidence differently from the court, it asks that the defendant’s right of defense take priority, and that it would file additional applications and opinions.

Kim Bong-kyu’s side said it would call the commanders of the various units, including former Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun, former Defense Intelligence Command chief Noh Sang-won, former commander Lee Jin-woo and Kwak, as witnesses to prove that he did not know of the deployment to the National Assembly. Kim Bong-kyu’s side also argued that the first-instance view that a probe into election fraud at the National Election Commission would paralyze the functions of the National Assembly was wrong. Kim Bong-kyu’s side said elections have been held twice since Dec. 4, 2024, and applied for a fact-finding request asking the National Election Commission whether there had been any problem with its election administration. The court adopted the fact-finding request to the National Election Commission and the witness appearance of former Minister Kim Yong-hyun, but did not accept former commander Noh Sang-won, who refused to testify in the first instance. It decided to determine the matter of former commanders Lee Jin-woo and Kwak Jong-keun after seeing how the trial proceeds.

Kim Dae-woo’s side said it doubted the first instance’s treatment of former deputy head Kim Sang-yong as an investigation expert in recognizing an arrest order, and applied for a fact-finding request on his training history and for the testimony of the person who received the arrest order; the court adopted both. A decision on the five attendees of the ‘Lotteria meeting’ whom Jung Seong-wook’s side applied to call as witnesses was put on hold.

## Defense questions status of special counsel’s seconded prosecutors after launch of Prosecution Service

The defendants’ side also questioned the qualifications of the special counsel’s prosecutors who appeared in court. It argued that, after the Prosecutors’ Office was replaced by the Prosecution Service, which launched on Oct. 2, it must first be confirmed whether the prosecutors seconded to the special counsel have a lawful secondment order and who the appointing authority is. The special counsel’s military prosecutor said he had been seconded by a personnel order of the Navy Headquarters.

The court said a personnel order dated Oct. 22 had been issued and the special counsel had submitted a command letter, adding that “they appear to have been granted authority in connection with maintaining the prosecution.” The court said it would file the relevant documents in the record. Defense counsel said they would check the command letter and the secondment order themselves and would raise an objection to the appointment and dismissal of prosecutors at every trial date to come.

## Heavier sentence for the commander who went than for the commander who gave the order

Seoul Central District Court Criminal Collegiate Division 37-2 (presiding Judge Oh Chang-seop) sentenced Kim to 12 years in prison on Aug. 27 and took him into custody in the courtroom. At the closing hearing on July 28, the special counsel described Kim as an ‘action commander’ who used violence on the orders of superiors and sought 18 years in prison. The court found that Kim directed the blockade of and entry into the National Assembly knowing the purpose was to block a vote on a resolution demanding the lifting of martial law and to drag lawmakers out. The court rejected his claim that he was following a superior’s orders, saying, “The orders the defendant received were manifestly unlawful, and the defendant was also aware of this.”

Another panel reached a different result on the same dispatch to the National Assembly. Kwak, who ordered the dispatch, was sentenced to nine years in prison on Sept. 21 by Criminal Collegiate Division 26\. Kwak admitted most of the charges during the trial, and the special counsel said it had taken into account that he cooperated in uncovering the substantive truth. Eight servicemen, including Kim Se-woon, former commander of the Special Operations Aviation Group, who led the unit that carried 707th troops to the National Assembly by helicopter, were all acquitted on Oct. 30 by Criminal Collegiate Division 38-2\. That panel found that they “had no choice but to concentrate on carrying out their mission on the premise that the superior’s order, handed down in great haste, was lawful.”

| Defendant       | Position (at the time)                                                       | Special counsel’s sentencing request | First-instance sentence                          | Sentencing date · panel                        |
| --------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------- |
| Kwak Jong-keun  | Former Special Warfare commander (ordered the dispatch)                      | 20 years in prison                   | 9 years in prison                                | 2026-09-21 · Criminal Collegiate Division 26   |
| Kim Hyun-tae    | Former 707th Special Mission Group commander (field commander)               | 18 years in prison                   | 12 years in prison (taken into custody in court) | 2026-08-27 · Criminal Collegiate Division 37-2 |
| Lee Sang-hyun   | Former 1st Airborne Special Forces Brigade commander                         | Not confirmed                        | 10 years in prison                               | 2026-08-27 · Criminal Collegiate Division 37-2 |
| Kim Bong-kyu    | Former head of Defense Intelligence Command central interrogation unit       | Not confirmed                        | 7 years in prison                                | 2026-08-27 · Criminal Collegiate Division 37-2 |
| Jung Seong-wook | Former head of 2nd Business Unit, Defense Intelligence Command 100th Brigade | Not confirmed                        | 7 years in prison                                | 2026-08-27 · Criminal Collegiate Division 37-2 |
| Kim Dae-woo     | Former head of Defense Counterintelligence Command investigation unit        | Not confirmed                        | 5 years in prison                                | 2026-08-27 · Criminal Collegiate Division 37-2 |
| Park Heon-su    | Former head of Defense Ministry Investigation Headquarters                   | Not confirmed                        | Not guilty                                       | 2026-08-27 · Criminal Collegiate Division 37-2 |
| Ko Dong-hee     | Former head of Defense Intelligence Command planning office                  | Not confirmed                        | Not guilty                                       | 2026-08-27 · Criminal Collegiate Division 37-2 |
| Kim Se-woon     | Former Special Operations Aviation Group commander                           | Not confirmed                        | Not guilty                                       | 2026-10-30 · Criminal Collegiate Division 38-2 |

## Kim says first press conference was due to distorted information and shifts position to say martial law was justified

Kim held a press conference in front of the War Memorial of Korea in Yongsan, Seoul, on Dec. 9, 2024, six days after martial law was lifted. In tears, Kim said, “The troops are the most pitiable victims, used by former Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun,” and said he would take full responsibility because he was the one who gave the order to blockade and enter the National Assembly. His account of having been told by Kwak that there must not be more than 150 lawmakers also first emerged at this press conference. The press conference, which was meant to shield his subordinates, was later used in the first instance as grounds against him.

Kim has repeatedly said that at the time of that press conference he was in no position to know the whole picture of martial law. Testifying as a witness at the sixth hearing of former President Yoon Suk Yeol’s impeachment trial at the Constitutional Court on Feb. 6, 2025, Kim said the mission he received from Kwak at 10:31 p.m. on the night martial law was declared was to blockade and secure the National Assembly building. Kim said Kwak told him “it must not exceed 150 people,” but that he did not think about what that meant, that he did not hear an order to “drag them out,” and that the word “lawmakers” was never used. On Feb. 3, 2026, Kim wrote on Facebook: “No one but Minister Kim Yong-hyun knew the purpose and intent of President Yoon Suk Yeol’s emergency martial law.” In the first-instance court, too, Kim said, “I didn’t know at the time, did I?”, and, “I didn’t know then, and my thoughts became clearer as time passed.”

Of his first press conference, Kim said in the first-instance defendant questioning on July 21, 2026: “I held the press conference on the basis of distorted information.” Kim also said the troops at the time were “under pressure that they would go to prison for insurrection.” His explanation is that, under pressure that his subordinates could be punished, he went into the press conference without knowing the reality of martial law.

Kim later claimed that Kwak’s statements had changed because of inducement by the Democratic Party. National Assembly National Defense Committee Chair Sung Il-jong said that after meeting Kim on Feb. 12, 2025, Kim told him he had been “completely used by the Democratic Party lawmakers.” At the Feb. 17 National Defense Committee hearing on current issues, Kim testified that when lawmaker Kim Byung-joo came to the Special Warfare Command right after martial law, Kwak forced the meeting through, saying, “I’ll make sure you don’t get hurt,” and that “we prepared our answers together using the list of expected questions that Lawmaker Kim passed on.” Just before the Dec. 10, 2024 plenary session of the National Defense Committee, Kim said, “A man who said he was a Democratic Party staff expert talked with Kwak for a long time. He said, ‘The tide has already turned. The Democratic Party will protect you.’” Kim added that lawmaker Park Beom-kye, who came next, wrote Kwak’s words on a yellow memo pad and, saying “You didn’t do it that way earlier,” demanded that he say exactly what the memo said, and that he recalled lawmaker Boo Seung-chan saying he would introduce a lawyer. Asked whether there had been inducement, Kim did not answer, but said he was “worried that Kwak’s statements may have been altered.”

After his dismissal, Kim spoke more plainly. On Facebook on Feb. 3, 2026, Kim wrote that lawmaker Kim Byung-joo phoned Kwak on Dec. 5, 2024 and “shook Commander Kwak Jong-keun’s resolve with inducement and threats,” and claimed that Kwak was induced “on Dec. 10, at lunchtime, in Room 333 of the National Assembly,” in Kim’s presence. Kim wrote that Kwak “seems to have given in to the Democratic Party’s inducement and threats,” while adding that “it may have been an unavoidable choice to save his subordinates.” The Democratic Party denied any inducement. Lawmaker Kim Byung-joo rebutted at a National Defense Committee meeting on Feb. 20, 2025: “There was no inducement whatsoever,” and lawmakers Park Beom-kye and Boo Seung-chan also said it was not true. Kwak later became a key witness who claimed he had received an order from former President Yoon Suk Yeol to drag lawmakers out. Who induced whom has not been settled by any investigation or trial to date, and the Democratic Party lawmakers whom Kim’s side applied to call as witnesses on the 2nd will not take the stand.

Kim also changed his view on martial law itself. In the July 21 defendant questioning, Kim said: “Emergency martial law is the president’s inherent power guaranteed by the Constitution,” and “so I think emergency martial law is lawful.” When the court asked, “Do you think emergency martial law was justified?”, Kim answered, “Yes. I still think so.” On Facebook as well, Kim wrote that the Democratic Party “is branding the president’s lawful emergency martial law as insurrection.” In his closing statement in the first instance, Kim said: “In a liberal democracy, soldiers who moved on instructions must never be branded as scapegoats.”

## Lee Jae-myung government’s Defense Ministry dismissed Kim seven months before first-instance ruling

The Defense Ministry under the Lee Jae-myung government held a disciplinary committee on Jan. 23, 2026 and resolved on heavy discipline for four colonels indicted on charges of participating in key insurrection duties, and on the 29th announced the dismissal of four, including Kim. Ko Dong-hee, the former planning office head dismissed along with him, was found not guilty in the first instance on Aug. 27\. On Feb. 12, Defense Minister Ahn Gyu-back announced the results of the activities of the Constitution-Respecting Government Innovation Task Force (TF) and said legal and administrative measures are being taken against “a total of about 180 people,” including 114 subjects of investigation. On Jan. 30, the day after the dismissal announcement, Kim wrote on Facebook: “It was a shameful disciplinary procedure that turned away from the truth and settled the outcome in advance.”

After his dismissal, Kim ran as an independent in the June 3 by-election for the Incheon Gyeyang-B National Assembly seat. Incheon Gyeyang-B is the constituency where President Lee Jae-myung served as a lawmaker before his election. According to the National Election Commission’s vote count, Kim won 9,248 votes (13.01%) and came third.

## First trial hearing on the 17th… Kim to state grounds for appeal on the 26th

The court decided to hold the first trial hearing at 10 a.m. on the 17th. That morning it will hear the special counsel’s grounds for appeal, those of defendants Kim Dae-woo, Lee Sang-hyun, Kim Bong-kyu and Jung Seong-wook, and the response of former planning office head Ko Dong-hee. The court decided to proceed, as in the first instance, by splitting the National Assembly dispatch portion and the National Election Commission portion. The defendants’ side requested four hours to state their grounds for appeal, Kim’s side eight hours, and the special counsel two hours for rebuttal. Kim’s side’s statement of grounds for appeal will be heard on the afternoon of the 26th.

The court then set trial dates on alternate Thursdays, scheduling through Jan. 21, 2027\. Hearings start at 10 a.m. and may run into the afternoon. No date was set that day for decisions on the petition to revoke detention and the motion to request a constitutional review.

| Date             | Event                                                                                                                                                                                  |
| ---------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| 2024-12-03 night | Emergency martial law declared. Kim, after receiving a call from Kwak, dispatches 707th troops to the National Assembly                                                                |
| 2024-12-09       | Kim’s press conference: “The troops are the most pitiable victims, used”                                                                                                               |
| 2025-02-06       | Testimony at Constitutional Court impeachment trial: “I did not hear an order to ‘drag them out’”                                                                                      |
| 2025-02-17       | National Assembly National Defense Committee hearing on current issues; testifies to circumstances of inducement of Kwak, including the remark “The Democratic Party will protect you” |
| 2026-01-29       | Defense Ministry announces dismissal of four colonels, including Kim                                                                                                                   |
| 2026-02-03       | Facebook: “the Democratic Party’s inducement and threats,” “lawful emergency martial law”                                                                                              |
| 2026-06-03       | Incheon Gyeyang-B by-election. Kim finishes third with 9,248 votes (13.01%)                                                                                                            |
| 2026-07-21       | First-instance defendant questioning: “Emergency martial law is lawful… I still think so”                                                                                              |
| 2026-08-27       | First instance: 12 years in prison, taken into custody in court                                                                                                                        |
| 2026-09-21       | Kwak sentenced to 9 years in prison in first instance                                                                                                                                  |
| 2026-10-02       | Prosecution Service launched. Kim petitions for bail                                                                                                                                   |
| 2026-10-21       | Seoul High Court rejects bail                                                                                                                                                          |
| 2026-10-22       | Personnel order issued for prosecutors seconded to special counsel                                                                                                                     |
| 2026-10-30       | Eight servicemen, including Kim Se-woon, former Special Operations Aviation Group commander, acquitted in first instance                                                               |
| 2026-11-02       | Appeal preparatory hearing. Decision on site inspection deferred; Democratic Party lawmakers not adopted as witnesses                                                                  |
| 2026-11-17       | First trial hearing (grounds for appeal of special counsel and four defendants)                                                                                                        |
| 2026-11-26       | Kim’s side states grounds for appeal                                                                                                                                                   |

## Sources (KST)

- Seoul High Court Criminal Division 12-2 · 2026-11-02 14:30 · Preparatory hearing in the case of 2026No2154, participating in key insurrection duties, etc. (BNN courtroom coverage)
- Constitutional Court · 2025-02-06 · Case 2024Hun-Na8, impeachment trial of the President (Yoon Suk Yeol), sixth hearing, witness examination of Kim Hyun-tae
- National Assembly National Defense Committee · 2025-02-17 · 422nd National Assembly (extraordinary session) National Defense Committee hearing on current issues, statements by Kim Hyun-tae
- Seoul Central District Court Criminal Collegiate Division 37-2 · 2026-07-21 14:00 · Defendant questioning in the case of Kim Hyun-tae and others on participating in key insurrection duties
- Facebook of Kim Hyun-tae, former 707th Special Mission Group commander · posts of 2026-01-30 and 2026-02-03
- National Assembly National Defense Committee · 2025-02-20 · 422nd National Assembly (extraordinary session) 3rd National Defense Committee meeting minutes · https://record.assembly.go.kr/assembly/viewer/minutes/xml.do?id=52722&type=view&item=item5
- Ministry of National Defense · 2026-02-12 · Results of the Ministry of National Defense’s Constitution-Respecting Government Innovation TF (ministry briefing) · https://www.korea.kr/briefing/policyBriefingView.do?newsId=156744468
- National Election Commission Election Statistics System · 2026-06-04 count completed · 2026.06.03 by-elections National Assembly election results (Incheon Metropolitan City Gyeyang-B) · https://info.nec.go.kr/main/showDocument.xhtml?electionId=0020260603&topMenuId=VC&secondMenuId=VCCP09
- Wikimedia Commons · taken 2024-12-04 · South Korean soldiers outside the National Assembly (public domain) · https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:South\_Korean\_soldiers\_outside\_the\_National\_Assembly.png